"To me, music is nothing but fraud. The moment you play all the seven notes, music is completed. Then going on repeating it, in different permutations and combinations, is nothing short of cheating. The person who successfully cheats a large audience for an extended period is called the 'big' composer."
This was Ilaiyaraaja speaking in a 1989 interview with Frontline.
It is quite an audacious observation from someone who has
spent a lifetime composing music that has moved millions. There is humour in
the statement, certainly, perhaps even deliberate irreverence.
But beneath it lies a fascinating philosophical question: If
all the possibilities already exist, what does it mean to create something
original?
This particular observation has stayed with me over the
years. In fact, of everything Ilaiyaraaja has spoken about, I find his thoughts
on the nature of musical creation among the most fascinating.
It brought to mind Jorge Luis Borges and his short story The
Library of Babel. Borges imagines an infinite library containing every
conceivable combination of letters and words. Every possible book, every
meaningful sentence and every meaningless arrangement exists somewhere in this
library. Nothing is entirely new in the sense that every possible combination
has already been accounted for.
The connection of Borges to Ilaiyaraaja's observation is
intriguing.
If every possible arrangement of words already exists,
what does it mean for a writer to create something original?
If the seven swaras form the fundamental vocabulary of
music, are composers creating something entirely new, or discovering
possibilities within an existing universe of sound?
The question is not necessarily about whether originality is
an illusion. It is about what originality really means when the fundamental
elements are already available to everyone. Perhaps the genius lies not in
possessing a different vocabulary, but in recognising possibilities that others
have not yet discovered.
And this is where I find Ilaiyaraaja particularly
fascinating.
Growing up in a household of singers and people who
genuinely appreciated music, Ilaiyaraaja was never just another composer whose
songs happened to play in the background. His music was part of our everyday
conversations.
His compositions were listened to, discussed, examined and
celebrated.
When Lata Mangeshkar sang for Ilaiyaraaja, it was news.
When S. P. Balasubrahmanyam changed his voice to suit a
particular character or film, it was something people discussed.
When Ilaiyaraaja appeared in a film's title song or sang its
opening number, it was an event in itself.
These were not incidental details. They were moments that
generated excitement among people who followed music closely.
And that was only one part of the experience. There were the
countless songs, the unforgettable melodies, the interludes that could hold an
entire emotional world, the orchestration that seemed to take a life of its
own, and the extraordinary ability to make music speak when words fell short.
For many of us who grew up during that era, his music is
inseparable from memory. It belongs to childhood, family gatherings, journeys,
friendships, celebrations, heartbreaks and countless ordinary moments that have
acquired meaning with time.
Some songs take us back to people we have lost.
Others bring back places we may never visit again.
There are melodies that evoke an emotion before we have even
consciously recognised the memory associated with them.
That is perhaps one of the
most remarkable things about music. It can preserve an emotional experience
long after the circumstances that created it have disappeared.
There is a distinction between music that we enjoy and music
that becomes part of our lives. Raja's compositions have occupied that latter
space for generations.
What makes his musical journey even more remarkable is that
his genius is not confined to what he accomplished decades ago. His command
over musical traditions, his extraordinary understanding of orchestration, his
ability to bring Indian classical sensibilities into conversation with Western
classical structures, and his willingness to experiment across genres have been
widely acknowledged. His musical vocabulary has never been restricted by
geographical or cultural boundaries.
But what I find equally interesting is his continued
willingness to learn, explore and expand his understanding of music.
There is something intellectually admirable about a person
who has achieved so much and still remains curious. Recognition, success and
mastery can sometimes become comfortable resting places. The desire to keep
learning, to engage with unfamiliar traditions and to discover new
possibilities requires a different kind of intellectual disposition.
Even at this stage of his life, he continues to engage with
music beyond familiar boundaries. He does not appear content with being
remembered only for what he has already created.
That, to me, is another dimension of his genius. It is not
simply the ability to master a discipline. It is the refusal to believe that
mastery marks the end of exploration.
Coming back to his 1989 interview, what makes the
conversation particularly interesting is that Ilaiyaraaja does not restrict his
reflections to the seven notes and their permutations. He ventures into a much
larger understanding of sound, rhythm and the universe.
He speaks of sound as something that extends beyond what
human beings ordinarily perceive. The universe itself has rhythms and patterns,
and our understanding of sound is limited by the boundaries of human
perception.
This is a fascinating way of approaching music. It shifts
the discussion from composition as a purely human activity to the possibility
that music is also an attempt to recognise and interpret something that already
exists around us.
Music is about the spaces between the notes. It is about
treating silence as an essential part of musical expressionIt is about being
attuned to the rhythms everywhere: in nature, in the movement of celestial
bodies, in the changing seasons, in the cycles of life and in the rhythms of
our own existence.
The human mind tends to separate these experiences
into different categories. Music belongs to art, rhythm to mathematics, nature
to science and existence to philosophy. But a mind that approaches the universe
through music may recognise connections that are less obvious to the rest of
us.
I find this particularly compelling about Ilaiyaraaja. He
seems to approach music not merely as an art to be practised, but as a
phenomenon to be contemplated. And perhaps that is why his music can sometimes
communicate something we struggle to put into words.
His spirituality and religious convictions are often
discussed alongside his musical genius. His philosophical observations are
sometimes interpreted through the lens of his spiritual beliefs, and his
relationship with the divine is an important part of how many people understand
him.
I find that dimension interesting too. However, I think
there is a distinction worth making.
His intellectual stature does not depend on his
spirituality. Even if one were to set aside his religious convictions,
spiritual experiences and the saintly qualities that admirers sometimes
attribute to him, there would still remain an extraordinarily fascinating mind.
His questions about the nature of sound, the universe,
creativity, perception and existence are worthy of exploration in their own
right.
Spirituality may offer one framework through which he
interprets the world. Philosophy allows us to examine the questions he raises.
Music gives those questions an expression that transcends language. These
dimensions may intersect, but they need not be treated as interchangeable.
One need not agree with every philosophical or metaphysical
position he holds to appreciate the questions he raises. Intellectual
engagement does not require unquestioning acceptance. In fact, the most
interesting ideas are often those that invite us to question our own
assumptions.
Perhaps originality is not about creating something from
nothing. It is about seeing something familiar differently.
A writer works with an existing language. A painter works
with colours that have always existed. A composer works with notes that have
been available for centuries. Yet some writers produce sentences that stay with
us for a lifetime, some painters make us see the ordinary world differently,
and some composers create music that seems to belong to every generation.
The elements may be shared. The way a mind perceives,
understands and brings them together is not.
This brings me back to Borges and his infinite library. If
every possible combination already exists, perhaps the wonder lies in
discovering the one that speaks to us. And if every possible musical
arrangement is already contained within the universe of sound, perhaps the
composer's genius lies in finding the arrangement that makes us feel something
we did not know we could feel.
We have grown up listening to Ilaiyaraaja. His music has
been part of our collective memory for decades. We know the melodies, recognise
the interludes, anticipate the familiar musical phrases and associate his
compositions with moments that have shaped our lives.
Yet I suspect that we are still discovering the depth of the
mind behind the music.
Musical genius is not always exhausted by the works it
produces. Sometimes, the ideas, intellectual explorations and questions behind
those works take much longer to understand. Each generation approaches an
artist with a different sensibility, a different body of knowledge and a
different set of questions. What one generation experiences primarily as music,
another may examine through the lenses of musicology, philosophy, neuroscience,
mathematics or metaphysics.
I am certain that generations will continue to peel away
these layers, discovering dimensions of his musical genius and intellectual
depth that we may not fully appreciate today.
Perhaps the greatest artists do more than leave behind
extraordinary bodies of work. They leave behind questions that remain relevant
long after the applause has faded.
For me, Ilaiyaraaja is not merely a composer whose music has
accompanied my life. He is an artist whose understanding of music, sound and
existence continues to make me curious.
We have spent decades listening to him.
The next generations may spend decades understanding him.
.jpg)


